Close Menu
Syracuse New TimesSyracuse New Times
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • Jump to Category…
    • All Events
    • Club Dates
    • Comedy
    • Exhibits
    • Film
    • Fundraisers
    • Learning
    • Literati
    • Outings
    • Other
    • Specials
    • Sports
    • Stage
    • Trivia
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    Syracuse New TimesSyracuse New Times
    Demo
    • CNY Events Calendar
      • Add My Event
      • Advertise On Calendar
    • News
      • News
      • Business
      • Sports
    • Arts
      • Art
      • Stage
      • Music
      • Film
      • Television
    • Lifestyle
      • Food
      • Wellness
      • Fashion
      • Travel
    • Opinion & Blogs
      • Things That Matter (Luke Parsnow)
      • New York Skies (Cheryl Costa)
    • Photos
    • Special Editions
      • 2019 Spring Times
      • 2019 Winter Times Edition
      • 2018 Holiday Times
      • 2018 SALT Awards
      • 2018 Best of Syracuse
      • 2018 Autumn Times
      • 2018 SNT Student Survival Guide
      • The 2018 Arts Issue
      • 2018 Summer Times
    • Family Times Magazine
    • CNY Community Guide
    Syracuse New TimesSyracuse New Times
    Home»Opinion & Blogs»Lawmakers Still Get Paid During Shutdowns They Create
    Opinion & Blogs

    Lawmakers Still Get Paid During Shutdowns They Create

    Luke ParsnowBy Luke ParsnowJanuary 31, 2018Updated:February 8, 2018No Comments5 Mins Read0 Views
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Telegram Tumblr Email
    Shutdown
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    We would really like to think of Congress as the best of us. As the upholders of law and order, we expect them to meet high standards. We also expect them to be treated no more favorably than the voters who sent them to Washington. Last week, our representatives managed to fail us on both accounts.

    For the second time in less than five years, the federal government was shut down for three days, the result of the same old political gridlock. During these shutdowns, federal employees aren’t able to work, national parks are closed and some members of the military aren’t paid.

    But the government shutdowns never actually shut down the paychecks received by the members of the House of Representatives and Senate.

    It is one of the most frustrating bugs in our system. The 27th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution — which was first introduced in the early days of the republic but wasn’t ratified until 1992 — restricts any Congress from changing its own pay. While this provision prevents Congress from being able to raise their own salaries, it also means that the only government workers who still get paid are the ones who cause shutdowns in the first place.

    If lawmakers really struggle to grasp why so many Americans feel that politicians believe they are above the law, look no further than the recent shutdown stalemate on Capitol Hill. How can people believe their representatives don’t get special treatment if they don’t appear to follow the basic social norms that we abide by every day?

    If we don’t agree with our co-workers, we don’t get to hold our business hostage. If we fail a task as a team effort, we don’t get to play the blame game and point fingers at everyone but ourselves. And if we don’t do our job, we don’t get paid.

    It’s about time Republican and Democratic members of Congress start following the same protocols. Maybe then they’ll think twice about shutting down the government at the expense of thousands of federal workers and the well-being of millions of citizens.

    Congress received enormous backlash during the two-week shutdown in 2013 when the topic of paychecks became part of the conversation. When Nebraska Republican Rep. Lee Terry was asked if he would still be collecting his paycheck during the shutdown, he replied, “Dang straight. I’ve got a nice house and a kid in college, and I’ll tell you we cannot handle it. Giving our paycheck away when you still worked and earned it? That’s just not going to fly.”

    Terry received little sympathy from people on that score.

    Fortunately, there are lawmakers who feel differently — or at least are good at looking like they feel differently. Since the 2013 shutdown, several lawmakers from both political parties have proposed legislation that would prevent members of Congress from receiving pay during government shutdowns.

    Hours before last week’s shutdown began, 10 Democratic senators introduced a bill that would do just that. Central New York’s own Rep. Claudia Tenney, the Republican representing the Mohawk Valley, also introduced a companion bill in the House.

    That maneuver is also good political theatrics. Since congressional paychecks are protected by a constitutional amendment, it would take more than a single bill to alter that. And there are many members of Congress who probably aren’t interested in docking their own pay, even if it is good optics.

    Since they can’t ban shutdown paychecks, many have resorted to announcing that they will donate them to good causes. Tenney said she was donating her shutdown first-day payment to the CNY Veterans Outreach Center and day two’s paycheck to the UHS New Horizons, a drug treatment center in Binghamton. Rep. John Katko, of New York’s 24th Congressional District, said his pay would be going to Vera House and PEACE, Inc.’s Head Start program.

    Yet even that process can be abused. Lawmakers must first receive that individual paycheck, then donate it themselves. According to The Washington Times, several politicians who made the pledge to return their pay during the 2013 shutdown still received it, just at a later date.

    As another government shutdown looms on Feb. 8 when the temporary spending plan expires, we might very well be repeating the conversation of shutdown payroll. But while Congress is immune from the no-work no-pay benchmark, they are not immune from this prospect: If you don’t do good work, you get fired.

    Since this is an election year, maybe it’s time we introduce some of our representatives to that social norm. Maybe then they’ll get the message.

    Continue Reading

    photo gallery
    Photo Galleries
    calendar
    Local Calendar
    news and opinion
    News and Opinion
    blog
    Blogs
    Arts
    Arts                    
    lifestyle
    Lifestyle
    blogs things that matter
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Luke Parsnow
    Luke Parsnow
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)

    Luke Parsnow is a digital content producer at Spectrum News CNY and an award-winning columnist at The Syracuse New Times. In his blog, "Things That Matter," he discusses topics that you should know about in today's society.

    Related Posts

    How Preparedness Shapes Resilient Communities

    December 3, 2024

    Blog | UFO news, disclosure and the demise of a great newspaper

    June 26, 2019

    Column | Despite financial hardships, people still want local journalism

    June 26, 2019

    Column | Cuomo will never win a popularity contest, yet he keeps winning gubernatorial elections

    June 19, 2019

    Column | Never Forget: Sacrifices made by the Greatest Generation on D-Day led to 75 years of world peace

    June 12, 2019

    Column | It’s time for Trump to release his tax returns

    June 5, 2019

    Comments are closed.

    • CNY Events Calendar
    • Club Dates
    • Food & Drink
    • Destinations
    • Sports & Outdoors
    • Family Times
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Community Code of Conduct
    • Staff/Contact Us
    • Careers
    • SALT Academy Applications & Awards Process
    • Family Times
    • CNY Tix
    • Spinnaker Custom Products

    Syracuse New Times
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest YouTube Dribbble
    © 2025 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.